Summary. A thirty-percent spread between three quotes does not mean the difference is margin. Normalise the basis first, then examine seven factors: own workshop versus brokered work, shop-drawing capability, live-site experience, safety and insurance, aftercare response, quote granularity, and three questions that eliminate half the field.
Three quotes arrive: one low, one high, one in between. The instinct is to discard the extremes and pick the middle, which works for standardised products and often fails for bespoke work - because you may not be comparing the same thing. This article is about making incomparable quotes comparable, and about the seven things beyond price that actually predict the outcome.
1. Normalise the basis before comparing numbers
The first step is not looking at figures but confirming all three quotes price the same thing. Align at least four items: the same drawing or method description revision, comparable material brands and grades, the same scope boundaries (freight, installation, derig, reinstatement), and the same programme and working window. The most common divergence is scope: one quote is 'materials delivered', another is 'installed and handed over', and the two numbers are not on the same plane. Send one standard enquiry list covering method, materials, boundaries and programme, ask everyone to quote in that format, and only then compare horizontally.
2. Own workshop or fully brokered
This determines three things: quality control, programme control, and the route to accountability when something goes wrong. A supplier with its own workshop controls purchasing through to factory inspection; a purely brokered supplier delivers whatever quality the subcontractor of that week provides, and the team may be different next time. You do not need a company registry search to judge it - ask three concrete questions: where is the workshop and can it be visited, which processes on this job are done in-house and which are outsourced, and what acceptance standard applies to the outsourced parts. Vague answers or a refusal to allow a visit usually mean fully brokered. Brokered does not necessarily mean bad, but it demands much stronger process control from the client.
3. Shop-drawing capability: renderings are not the dividing line
Anyone can produce a rendering; construction drawings are what separate capable suppliers. Ask for a node detail or as-built drawing from a previous project with client information redacted. If all that arrives are renderings and finished photographs, with no nodes, dimensions or structural notes, the site crew will probably be improvising. A second signal is whether the supplier can explain fixing: point at a cantilever in the drawing and ask how it connects to the wall. A team that has actually built it will immediately describe the connection, fastener specification and substrate requirements; 'we will see on site' is a warning.
4. Live-site experience: a trading mall is not a building site
Commercial interiors carry far more constraints than ordinary construction: night working, timed access, dust and noise limits, fire egress, concurrent neighbouring tenants. A crew without that experience tends to struggle on day one - missing tools, non-compliant barriers, stopped by property management. Ask specific questions: when did you last work in a mall, what were that site's working hours, how did materials move through the goods lift, were you ever required to rectify something? People who have done it answer in detail, down to the lift's rated load and how many trips it took.
5. Safety and insurance: someone has to carry the risk
These projects involve work at height, temporary power and hot work, so the risk is real. Confirm two things: accident or employment insurance for the crew, and third-party liability insurance. Both are usually hidden costs in a quotation, and one incident costs far more than the saving. Then check whether safety measures exist as documents: a method statement for work at height, a hot-work permit, a compliant temporary power scheme. Ask for a redacted safety briefing record or access approval from a previous job; a supplier willing to provide one is running a real process.
6. Aftercare response: a warranty period is not an aftercare capability
Many quotes say 'two-year warranty' without stating how quickly someone attends, who pays, or what is excluded. Those three gaps make the warranty almost unusable in practice. Compare the response mechanism instead: the reporting channel, committed response time, attendance time, whether spares exist for common faults, and how remote sites are handled. Ask for a sentence in the contract such as 'respond within X hours of notice, attend within Y days'. It is worth more than the number of years.
7. Quote granularity: will they break it down?
A single total and a quote split into materials, processes, labour, freight and installation convey very different amounts of information. A detailed breakdown shows where the money goes and lets variations be priced against comparable items; with a lump sum, a variation can only be priced at whatever the supplier says. Detailed does not mean cheaper - it can be higher, because every item has been costed - but it makes 'is this expensive?' discussable. When several suppliers quote in the same detailed format, the line that creates the difference is usually obvious.
8. Three questions that eliminate half the field
First: 'Under what conditions would this method fail?' A good supplier names concrete conditions - substrate moisture above a threshold, ambient temperature below a minimum, load beyond a figure. 'It cannot fail' usually means they have not really done it or will not say. Second: 'If site conditions differ from the drawings, what do you do?' The right answer is to stop, raise it in writing and wait for confirmation, not adjust on the spot; 'we will handle it on site' means uncontrolled change.
Third: 'What were you dissatisfied with on the last job?' A supplier who can discuss a problem plainly is generally more reliable than one with nothing but success stories. Together these three questions reveal more about delivery capability than a portfolio does.
From the workshop
How we work
The seven-step process from brief to crated delivery, plus how quotations are built.
Read process →Export & terms
Packing, documentation, freight terms and what an overseas buyer needs to confirm.
Read terms →Three ways into the material
Technique articles explain how the work is made. Buyer insights explain how a project is specified, approved and accepted. The Q&A section answers the questions that come up before a quotation is agreed.
Technical knowledge base
22 in-depth articles on materials, processes, installation QA and applications.
Open section →Buyer insights
7 long-form guides on contracts, site access, acceptance, briefing and aftercare.
Open section →Tell us what you are building
Send photos, dimensions, the destination country and your target date. You will get a technique recommendation, a reference price band and a production schedule - no obligation.
Request a quoteHow export works